sorry I hate to ask this kind of question here but I'm on a mission to find some floor mats I can be happy with, I spent $80 in the past and got some 'molded floor mats' but they just never fit right. I'm not looking for anything fancy just something that'll catch dirt/mud/snow, preferably black to match black interior, its a 96 4 door

Huskyliners are the only way to go....http://www.huskyliner.com/floorliners.html

ditto, I just got a pair for my 93 and they fit beautifully

wheres a good place to order them from online? or from a store like advanced auto parts or autozone?

i bought some stuff here before and havent had any problems, FREE SHIPPING TODAY TOO :)
http://www.autoanything.com/category.aspx?c_id=50193&se=husky_liners_floor_mats

I bought backs and fronts at walmart. They hold about a inch of melted snow without running out everywhere. They are grooved out all over for no slipping too. They were so great I have bought them for 3 vehicles so far. $15 for fronts, $10 for rears. Come in black, grey, tan, clear.