Hi

I have a 1998 E39 535i that has a knocking sound coming from the front right wheel area. The noise can be heard mainly at low speeds and when touching the brake (not only when touching the brake though). It sounds like a load of golf balls rattling around in the bottom of a golf bag.

The car has been to BMW who changed discs and pads to no effect and in the last week I have taken it to an independent mechanic who cannot find anything wrong with the brakes or wheel bearings.

I have been assured that the sound is not dangerous but it is driving me up the wall!!!!

I should also mention that it only seems to occur when the vehicle is warm.

Any ideas anyone please?

Regards

AZZA

I'd still be skeptical of the brakes. Maybe the caliper/hardware shifting back and forth. A determined professional shop WILL find the noise, and charge accordingly for their efforts.

hi azza
i think i know your car problem with that voice his voice comes from the susbention top fit the nut maybe losen or the disk bearing need to change this dish wich fix the chock absorber
chick and good luck
khaled
Hi

I have a 1998 E39 535i that has a knocking sound coming from the front right wheel area. The noise can be heard mainly at low speeds and when touching the brake (not only when touching the brake though). It sounds like a load of golf balls rattling around in the bottom of a golf bag.

The car has been to BMW who changed discs and pads to no effect and in the last week I have taken it to an independent mechanic who cannot find anything wrong with the brakes or wheel bearings.

I have been assured that the sound is not dangerous but it is driving me up the wall!!!!

I should also mention that it only seems to occur when the vehicle is warm.

Any ideas anyone please?

Regards

AZZA

Pink Panther makes sense to me. :D

Loose nut on the top of the shock tower, I think, is what he's getting at.

i have same problem. i replaced front wheel bearing...

Q&E Auto Parts has the replacement part you are looking for. With a wide variety of both OEM and aftermarket items, your car will soon be as good as new. We carry parts for your vehicle such as A/C Compressor, Gasket Set, Belt Tensioner, Brake Master Cylinder, Camshaft Seal, Crank Position Sensor, Distributor Cap & Rotor, Electric Fuel Pump, Engine Mount, Fresh Air Filter, Front & Rear Brake Disc, Front & Rear Brake Pad Set, Front & Rear Control Arm, Front & Rear Stabilizer Link, Fuel Filter, Ignition Coil, Ignition Wire Set, Oil Filter, Oxygen Sensor, Power Steering Pump, Propeller Shaft Flex Disc, Radiator Fan Motor, Rear C.V Joint Boot, Rear Shock Absorber,Rear Wheel Hub, Serpentine Belt, Spark Plug, Thermostat, Tie Rod End, Timing Chain, Transmission Mount, Water Pump & Gasket, Windshield Washer Pump & Blade, and others for all BMW models. With top quality brand names such as Bosch, Brembo, Bilstein, Continental, Lemförder, Reinz, Mann, Mahle, Sachs, Eurospare, and a 1 year warranty on all our products your purchase is guaranteed. If you have any questions or concerns please contact our staff at cristhian@qeautoparts.com or javier@qeautoparts.com or give us a call at 305-509-5063 (Monday to Saturday).
Please visit our online store at www.qeautoparts.com (http://www.qeautoparts.com/). Our excellent prices and quality items are waiting for you.